Article-pilier
Nicotine substitutes: a complete guide to patches, gums, lozenges and sprays for quitting smoking
Patch, gum, lozenge, spray, inhaler: how to choose your nicotine substitute, the right dose, how to combine, what it costs, how it is reimbursed.
Nicotine substitutes (or NRT, nicotine replacement therapy) are the first line of medical aid to quit smoking. They are effective, cheap, reimbursed in most European countries, and far smarter to use than what you usually read about them.
Here is everything you need to choose, dose and combine them correctly.
How it works
When you smoke, your brain gets a nicotine shot in 7 to 10 seconds. When you stop abruptly, withdrawal sets in within 4 to 24 hours and triggers the withdrawal syndrome (irritability, anxiety, strong cravings).
Nicotine substitutes deliver nicotine alone, without the 7,000 other substances in smoke — no tar, no carbon monoxide, no fine particles. Your brain gets what it asks for, your body is no longer poisoned.
The different forms: patch, gum, lozenge, spray, inhaler
| Form | Action | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|
| Patch (16h or 24h) | Slow, continuous | One application/day, discreet, stable release | Will not soothe an acute craving |
| Gum (2 mg or 4 mg) | Fast (5-10 min) | Soothes a one-off craving | Strong taste, possible hiccups |
| Lozenge | Fast | More discreet than gum | Do not chew |
| Sublingual tablet | Fast | Very discreet, no taste | Less common |
| Inhaler | Fast + gesture | Recreates the act of smoking | More expensive, more visible |
| Mouth spray | Very fast (60s) | Eases the strongest urges | Strong taste, can sting |
Find the right dose: do not underdose
The most frequent mistake: starting with a dose too low out of fear or guilt. Result: withdrawal persists, you crack, you relapse, and you conclude 'patches do not work'. They do — it was the dose that was wrong.
The winning combo: patch + fast form
This is the strategy validated by the Cochrane meta-analyses (review of more than 130 studies, 64,000 smokers).
Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2023 update
Why? The patch keeps a stable nicotine background. The fast form (gum, lozenge, spray) handles one-off craving spikes — after coffee, in the car, in a stressful situation. Without the fast form, those spikes are not covered by the patch and often trigger a relapse.
How long to use a substitute?
- Before quit day Starting the patch 2 to 4 weeks before your quit date increases the chances of success (Cochrane study). You smoke in parallel, no fear.
- D0 to 8 weeks Full dose. You have no reason to lower the dose if cravings persist.
- Weeks 8-12 Gradual reduction (step down to a lower dose). Not mandatory if it destabilises you.
- Beyond No evidence that going beyond 8-12 weeks adds extra benefit, but no documented risk either if you need it for 6 months or more.
Possible side effects
NRT is among the best-tolerated medicines.
Patch — skin irritation in about 1 in 5 people (changing the area each day usually solves it). Insomnia / vivid dreams with the 24h patch (switch to 16h then).
Gum — hiccups, throat burn, bloating (technique: 'chew a few times, park between cheek and gum, chew again when the urge returns'). Never swallow saliva like a normal chewing gum.
Lozenge — let it dissolve, do not chew. Same minor issues as the gum.
Spray — burning sensation in the mouth, sometimes sneezing.
If side effects bother you: change format, do not stop the treatment.
Common myths to forget
Special cases
Pregnancy and breastfeeding — NRT allowed when unaided cessation has failed (see dedicated article). 16h patches preferred over 24h. Bupropion and varenicline contraindicated.
Heart disease — NRT is less risky than continuing to smoke. Discuss with the cardiologist but no absolute contraindication.
Adolescents — prescription should come after age 15, with support. Younger: specialist advice.
Very high dependence (3+ packs/day) — a tobaccologist can prescribe doses higher than standard protocols.
How to get them
On prescription from a doctor, midwife, dentist, nurse, physiotherapist, or pharmacist (depending on country).
Free on the NHS in the UK via Stop Smoking Services, and reimbursed in many European countries (in France: 65 % with no annual cap since 2018).
Without prescription: also available over the counter at pharmacies, but without reimbursement.
Your questions
-
Which substitute is most effective?
All formats have a comparable effectiveness alone. But the patch + oral form combination is more effective than a single format: it is the reference method today. -
I cracked and smoked a cigarette while wearing the patch. Is it dangerous?
No. No study has shown particular toxicity. You are not overdosing. Keep the patch on, get back on track. -
Can I wear the patch at night?
With the 24h patch, yes (but possible vivid dreams or insomnia). With the 16h, you remove it at bedtime. If you light your first cigarette within 30 min after waking, the 24h is more suitable. -
How much does it really cost?
In the UK, NRT is free through Stop Smoking Services (NHS prescription, charge waived for most quitters). Without reimbursement, around £25-45 per month depending on the combination. Far cheaper than a month of cigarettes (~£450 at £15/pack). In France with 65 % reimbursement, you pay 10-18 € per month. -
Can I buy patches online, is it cheaper?
Be cautious. In the UK, buying through your local pharmacy or NHS Stop Smoking Service guarantees genuine MHRA-approved products. NRT bought from non-approved sites may contain incorrect doses. In France, the price is regulated and a registered pharmacy avoids counterfeits. -
How long should I use them?
8 to 12 weeks as standard. Longer if you need it — there is no penalty for extending. Better a patch for 6 months than relapsing in month 3. -
What about the e-cigarette? Is it also a substitute?
Vaping is not a medicine and is not reimbursed. It can be effective to quit tobacco, but its long-term effects are still under study. See the dedicated vaping article.
sources
Lindson N et al., Different doses, durations and modes of delivery of nicotine replacement therapy for smoking cessation, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2023 update.
Hartmann-Boyce J et al., Nicotine replacement therapy versus control for smoking cessation, Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2018 (136 studies, 64,640 participants).
NICE NG209, Tobacco: preventing uptake, promoting quitting and treating dependence, good practice recommendation, 2024 update.
Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency (MHRA), Nicotine replacement therapies — Recommendations for proper use, UK product guidance.
Office for Health Improvement and Disparities (OHID), Smoking cessation: which effective treatments?, 2024 dossier.
NHS, Stop smoking treatments — patches, gum, lozenges, sprays and inhalers, NHS.uk 2024 update.
related reading
understand
Is nicotine a drug or a medicine? Effects, addiction and common misconceptions about cigarettes
understand
Why do we get hooked on cigarettes? The mechanics of nicotine and tobacco addiction explained
quit
The tobacco withdrawal syndrome day by day: full calendar from D0 to D90
profiles
Pregnant women and tobacco: how to quit smoking during pregnancy, without guilt, step by step